Открытый доступ Открытый доступ  Ограниченный доступ Платный доступ или доступ для подписчиков

Hermione as a Russian: Is The Winter’s Tale an Alternative History?

Maria Eliferova


One of the enigmas of The Winter’s Tale is its specification that Hermione’s father was ‘the Emperor of Russia’. This detail is clearly derived from Greene’s Pandosto, however the biographies of the respective characters are switched. In Greene, ‘the Emperours daughter of Russia’ is the wife of Egistus, the character whose counterpart in Shakespeare is Polixenes (remember that Shakespeare reversed the countries as well, making Polixenes King of Bohemia rather than Sicily).

As of 1611 when The Winters Tale was likely written, only one Russian had officially declared himself Emperor – that is, False Dmitry I (long dead, having been killed in 1606). Greene who died in 1592 would not be able to know about him. There is, however, some evidence that the English would occasionally and informally refer to Ivan the Terrible as ‘Emperor’. What sort of historical reality is depicted by Greene and Shakespeare?

Apart from the non-existent (yet conceivable for the 16th-century English) figure of ‘Russian Emperor’, the sole oddity of Greene’s world is the fact that his (fictitious) characters worship pagan gods.  Along with the fictitious names of kings, these are the markers that efficiently remove the story from any historical context and create the sense of fairy-tale literary convention.

Shakespeare’s world, however, is much more complex. Shakespeare introduces in the story a geographic anomaly (the non-existent sea coast of Bohemia), clear signs of modernity (that is, the printing press and junk reading – his shepherdess are literate, but their reading tastes are deplorable), and, to have everything confused even more, Giulio Romano who had died well before Shakespeare’s birth and never practiced sculpture: yet Pauline claims that the paint on the alleged statue of his work is still wet. These oddities are, in fact, well explicable if one suggests that The Winter’s Tale belongs to the genre of alternative history: in this alternative world, Bohemia has sea coasts, Christianity is superseded by the restored paganism, literacy has spread much wider that in Shakespeare’s actual world, and Giulio Romano has become a sculptor.

Ключевые слова

alternative history; English-Russian connections; Shakespeare; The Winter’s Tale

Полный текст:



Aгеева 2012 – Агеева О.Г. От Московского царства к Всероссийской империи: акт поднесения императорского титула 22 октября (4 ноября) 1721 года // 1150 лет российской государственности и культуры. – М.: Наука, 2012. С. 109-121. (no English summary)

Кудрявцев 2016 – Кудрявцев О.Ф. “Kayser unnd Herscher aller Rewssen”: обращение к русскому государю как к императору в габсбургских документах первой трети XVI в. // Древняя Русь. 2016. №1(63). С. 41-55. = Kudryavtsev O.F. ‘“Kayser vnnd Herscher aller Rewssen”: the Calling of Russian Sovereign as Emperor in the Habsburg Documents of the First Third of the 16th Century’, Drevnyaya Rus’, 2016. No. 1(63). Pp. 41-46.

[English summary, no pagination]. – Accessed 1.09.2016.

Bate 2008 – Bate, Jonathan. Soul of the Age: The Life, Mind and World of William Shakespeare. London: Viking, 2008.

Bryant 1963 – Bryant, Jerry H. ‘The Winter's Tale and the Pastoral Tradition’, Shakespeare Quarterly, 1963. Vol. 14, No. 4. Pp. 387-398.

Cressy 2006 – Cressy, David. Literacy and the Social Order: Reading and Writing in Tudor and Stuart England. – Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2006.

Durants 1961 – Durant, Will; Durant, Ariel. The Age of Reason Begins: A History of European Civilization in the Period of Shakespeare, Bacon, Montaigne, Rembrandt, Galileo, and Descartes: 1558-1648. New York: Simon and Schuster, 1961.

Gilles 1994 – Gilles, John. Shakespeare and the Geography of Difference. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1994.

Hunt 1995 – The Winter’s Tale: Critical Essays. Ed. by Maurice Hunt. New York: Routledge, 1995.

Palmer 1995 – Palmer, Daryl W. ‘Jacobean Muscovites: Winter, Tyranny, and Knowledge in The Winter's Tale’, Shakespeare Quarterly, 1995. Vol. 46, No. 3. Pp. 323-339.

Salei 2002 – Salei, Siarhei. ‘Ivan the Terrible’s Imperial Title and Problem of Its Recognition in the West and in the East’, in Castrum, Urbs et Bellum. Zbornik navukovych prac, Baranavichy. 2002. Pp. 320-341.

Solodkin 2012 – Solodkin, Roman. ‘Project of the English Acquisition of Northern Russia in the Early 17th century in Russian Historiography’ = Солодкин Р.Я. Проект установления английского протектората на севере России (начало XVII столетия) в отечественной историографии // Вестник Тюменского государственного университета. 2012. №

С. 26-30.

Stronach 1903 – Stronach, George. ‘Shakespeare’s Geography’, Notes and Queries, Series 9, Vol. XI. Oxford, 1903. Pp. 469-470.

Szykuła 2012 – Szykuła, Krystyna. ‘Unexpected 16th Century Finding to Have Disappeared Just After Its Printing – Anthony Jenkinson’s Map of Russia, 1562’, in Cartography – A Tool for Spatial Analysis. Ed. by Carlos Bateira. S. l.: Intech, 2012. Pp. 119-152.

Thomas 2007 – Thomas, Alfred. A Blessed Shore: England and Bohemia from Chaucer to Shakespeare. Ithaca – London: Cornell University Press, 2007.


  • На текущий момент ссылки отсутствуют.


ISSN 2412-9674